Do you agree that there are two kinds of disabled people--people who are visibly disabled, and as a result tend have people overestimate their disability, so that they really desperately want people to be less likely to express sympathy for them and offer to do things for them; and people who are invisibly disabled, and have people constantly tell them to apply themselves and tough it out, and therefore really really enjoy it when someone tries to help them, even clumsily?
I find this idea impossible not to think about, just because of the symmetry. This is probably Like a Person Part Four I guess, but whatever. And also, disclaimer, there aren't really only two kinds, it's just that I am talking about two groups of disabled people, but there are other disabled people who aren't in either group, I'm sure.
I feel like--and not to be a dick, my parents are really nice and everything, but anyway--my parents have always made me be both kinds of people at once, meaning that they'd do lots of things for me that I had trouble doing, but they'd never stop reminding me that I should be doing those things, and it was really bad that I wasn't doing them. They did things like making a point of having me go and order food at McDonald's when I was a kid, because they knew that it was hard for me. So even when I was actually doing the things, I didn't feel normal, because it was A Lesson. I'm probably not being coherent. I don't have much time to write this.
Pretty much my only disabled friend (I have some friends who have mental illnesses but don't identify as disabled) is physically disabled, and he is super spoiled just like I am, rarely has a job, executive function skills are possibly worse than mine are, just learned to drive at age 21, last year his roommate would sometimes come up to me and say, "Can you please get FFD to put a sheet on his bed because he's sleeping on a mattress and it's grossing me out?" At the end of first year, his mom told him not to pack or clean his room, he'd worked hard enough, she would do it.
My parents got to school at the end of first year, and I wasn't done packing--I had taken all the paper off my walls, which you can imagine took a long time, and packed some clothes, but my room was very cluttered, when they came in. So my mom had a very negative reaction about how I was disorganized and hadn't done anything.
I'm kind of rambling and maybe shouldn't be posting this because it might be a gender thing instead of a visible/invisible disability thing, or just something completely different. I do think it's interesting, though.
Anyway, when my friend was in school, he was mostly in mainstream school, but at camp, and as a little kid, he was with kids who had severe intellectual and physical disabilities. He has this thing about how teachers would always tie his shoes for him instead of letting him do it, because it took him longer. Also when he was a kid he sometimes fell down and some bystander would make a production out of it even though he was obviously all right.
My teachers basically thought I was a major bitch and in fifth grade my teacher took me on as a project and forced eye contact on me while telling me how self-centered and arrogant I was until I started crying. She would also take books away from me to train me to talk to other kids, etc. etc. and basically snap at me if I said something she considered impossible, like, "I can't tell if I'm joking with someone or bullying them."
So, if a friend and I go to a movie theater or something like that, and my friend automatically does the talking for me, or if a friend brings me along to her boyfriend's house where there are a lot of people, and talks to her boyfriend in an attempt to find out if I could go play with his guitar, this is something that I find hugely touching and wonderful. Whereas, if I get up to plug in FFD's computer, or bring him his shoes or something, it makes him annoyed.
(I should give myself more time to write things, sorry; am I saying anything interesting?)
10 January, 2010
09 January, 2010
I'm building a habitat for myself.
For the past three years I've been a devotee of College Student Things, by which I mean Christmas lights and sticking pictures to the walls. I mean, I guess I always liked Christmas lights and I started with the pictures a little bit in the last few months of high school:

But then when I went to college, it all just sort of exploded out of me, like this:

Maybe you can't see the best part of the wall papers:

That part is photocopies of album covers and comic books, but the main thing that started to happen to my walls was that I put absolutely everything on them. I used tickets and receipts and little pieces of candy wrappers to fill in the inches of space between pictures and postcards.
Bizarrely I can't find that good a picture of second year, but that's okay because it wasn't that good, I just tried to recreate what I did in first year, which was kind of stupid. It takes a really long time to do this, and it didn't really help to try to follow a picture of what it was like the year before; it maybe even made it worse. Also, different stuff feels important at different times so I feel like part of my wall was on life support and was full of things that didn't feel important to me anymore.

Then when I went home for the summer, I finally decided not to live in my old room anymore. It's really big and it has really bright wallpaper that I thought I wanted for a minute when I was fourteen. It's just hard to concentrate or feel anything in that room. So I moved to the room I lived in when I was a baby; I didn't want to do stuff to all the walls, since I won't be living at home much longer, so I just put up Christmas lights and did the closet:

I don't know why I never took a better picture of it. Anyway, I understand that this stuff will be sort of obnoxious and hipster-y once I stop being in college, but I can't help it, I have a feeling I'm always going to live in environments like this, until I have kids who might trip over the Christmas lights and tear the pictures off the walls--AND ONCE I LIVE SOMEWHERE THAT I PLAN TO LIVE IN FOR SEVERAL YEARS, I COULD DO ALL THE WALLS!! EVERY INCH!!
I just got back to school and so far I have this:

And I forgot to bring BlueTac, but I didn't want to wait last night, so I just stuck things up for now with duct tape:


Obviously, this is revolting, but I can't help but be sort of thrilled by how little time it took, and wonder if maybe I don't really need to do a super precise pattern with no blank spaces.
I mean, I probably do. I'll fix it soon.

But then when I went to college, it all just sort of exploded out of me, like this:

Maybe you can't see the best part of the wall papers:

That part is photocopies of album covers and comic books, but the main thing that started to happen to my walls was that I put absolutely everything on them. I used tickets and receipts and little pieces of candy wrappers to fill in the inches of space between pictures and postcards.
Bizarrely I can't find that good a picture of second year, but that's okay because it wasn't that good, I just tried to recreate what I did in first year, which was kind of stupid. It takes a really long time to do this, and it didn't really help to try to follow a picture of what it was like the year before; it maybe even made it worse. Also, different stuff feels important at different times so I feel like part of my wall was on life support and was full of things that didn't feel important to me anymore.

Then when I went home for the summer, I finally decided not to live in my old room anymore. It's really big and it has really bright wallpaper that I thought I wanted for a minute when I was fourteen. It's just hard to concentrate or feel anything in that room. So I moved to the room I lived in when I was a baby; I didn't want to do stuff to all the walls, since I won't be living at home much longer, so I just put up Christmas lights and did the closet:

I don't know why I never took a better picture of it. Anyway, I understand that this stuff will be sort of obnoxious and hipster-y once I stop being in college, but I can't help it, I have a feeling I'm always going to live in environments like this, until I have kids who might trip over the Christmas lights and tear the pictures off the walls--AND ONCE I LIVE SOMEWHERE THAT I PLAN TO LIVE IN FOR SEVERAL YEARS, I COULD DO ALL THE WALLS!! EVERY INCH!!
I just got back to school and so far I have this:

And I forgot to bring BlueTac, but I didn't want to wait last night, so I just stuck things up for now with duct tape:


Obviously, this is revolting, but I can't help but be sort of thrilled by how little time it took, and wonder if maybe I don't really need to do a super precise pattern with no blank spaces.
I mean, I probably do. I'll fix it soon.
08 January, 2010
Language as maintenance
So basically, I think there are ways of being with people that don't involve exchanging strings of words, or are about something besides or more than words. I was thinking about this because I was trying to explain to myself in my head, in an objective way, why flapping your hands is not the same as masturbating in public or asking repetitive questions. Which means explaining exactly why it is that those other two things are invasive.
Hopefully we know why masturbating in public is invasive--you should only have sex with yourself or other people who have agreed to have sex with you; if you masturbate in public you are, on a mild level, performing a nonconsensual sexual act. The reason asking repetitive questions is invasive is because you are forcing another person to apply themselves to the task of trying to answer you, for no reason, because you don't actually stand to gain anything from their answer. It's like asking someone to tie your shoe when you can tie your own shoe. Of course I'm not trying to say that a person who does either of those things is intentionally trying to be invasive; especially if they're disabled or ill, they might not understand the context of what they're doing. I'm just saying that those two acts are objectively hurtful to other people, and I don't see how flapping your hands is in the same league.
But then, while I was thinking about repetitive questions, I immediately thought of situations where it seems perfectly okay to ask repetitive questions. A long time ago I made a post where I said that when I was really overloaded, I talked to my friend "in a way that was like holding hands." What I meant by this is that what I said didn't have a lot of content, and I was just saying it as a way of being with my friend. Also, last spring when I was volunteering a lot with intellectually disabled people, I developed a habit of just saying "hi" to people a lot in the middle of conversations. This is because I had started saying "hi" a lot to people with intellectual disabilities who couldn't speak or process language that well. When we kept saying "hi," looking at each other, and smiling, we were maintaining a connection over a period of time in a different way than the conventional method, exchanging information, which doesn't work for everyone.
So in this case, the word "hi" is not really a greeting, just maintenance, and it becomes something more/other than language. Another example of language as maintenance is something that A.T. did a lot in the last few days of the year. She made a cover for a book with an embarrassing title she was reading, and I wrote on the cover, "Dragon Love: A Romance Novel About Dragons." Over the next few days, when we were sitting quietly on a bus, or walking around, A.T. would sing in an odd, spooky-sounding melody, "dra-gon-love." I would laugh when she did this, so I guess you could call it an inside joke, but I feel like she wasn't doing it because she thought, "This will make Amanda laugh," but was just saying it without thinking of it, the way you would scratch your nose or put your hand in your pocket. Of course, I could be wrong, and I hesitate to say this because A.T. isn't a very affectionate person, but I have a theory that when she was singing "dra-gon-love," it was like how other people might hold hands with their friend or say something conventionally affectionate. It was a way of saying "even though we're not talking I'm still here with you."
Hopefully we know why masturbating in public is invasive--you should only have sex with yourself or other people who have agreed to have sex with you; if you masturbate in public you are, on a mild level, performing a nonconsensual sexual act. The reason asking repetitive questions is invasive is because you are forcing another person to apply themselves to the task of trying to answer you, for no reason, because you don't actually stand to gain anything from their answer. It's like asking someone to tie your shoe when you can tie your own shoe. Of course I'm not trying to say that a person who does either of those things is intentionally trying to be invasive; especially if they're disabled or ill, they might not understand the context of what they're doing. I'm just saying that those two acts are objectively hurtful to other people, and I don't see how flapping your hands is in the same league.
But then, while I was thinking about repetitive questions, I immediately thought of situations where it seems perfectly okay to ask repetitive questions. A long time ago I made a post where I said that when I was really overloaded, I talked to my friend "in a way that was like holding hands." What I meant by this is that what I said didn't have a lot of content, and I was just saying it as a way of being with my friend. Also, last spring when I was volunteering a lot with intellectually disabled people, I developed a habit of just saying "hi" to people a lot in the middle of conversations. This is because I had started saying "hi" a lot to people with intellectual disabilities who couldn't speak or process language that well. When we kept saying "hi," looking at each other, and smiling, we were maintaining a connection over a period of time in a different way than the conventional method, exchanging information, which doesn't work for everyone.
So in this case, the word "hi" is not really a greeting, just maintenance, and it becomes something more/other than language. Another example of language as maintenance is something that A.T. did a lot in the last few days of the year. She made a cover for a book with an embarrassing title she was reading, and I wrote on the cover, "Dragon Love: A Romance Novel About Dragons." Over the next few days, when we were sitting quietly on a bus, or walking around, A.T. would sing in an odd, spooky-sounding melody, "dra-gon-love." I would laugh when she did this, so I guess you could call it an inside joke, but I feel like she wasn't doing it because she thought, "This will make Amanda laugh," but was just saying it without thinking of it, the way you would scratch your nose or put your hand in your pocket. Of course, I could be wrong, and I hesitate to say this because A.T. isn't a very affectionate person, but I have a theory that when she was singing "dra-gon-love," it was like how other people might hold hands with their friend or say something conventionally affectionate. It was a way of saying "even though we're not talking I'm still here with you."
Labels:
asd,
intellectual disability,
language,
scripting,
stimming
so, I'm looking for summer jobs
and I want to work at this camp for ASD people (I wanted to last year, but didn't get it; hopefully this year I have a better chance because I'm applying earlier and have more experience). Anyway, look at this charming passage from their website:
Behaviors may by inappropriate (e.g., asking repetitive questions, flapping ones' hands, attempting to masturbate in public, etc.),
yeah you guys
those are all the SAME KIND OF THING
Behaviors may by inappropriate (e.g., asking repetitive questions, flapping ones' hands, attempting to masturbate in public, etc.),
yeah you guys
those are all the SAME KIND OF THING
07 January, 2010
really charming things people have said to me on the Internet
"What are your interests? My interests are California and Harry Potter...sorry, I'm being weird, I guess I'm at the lower-functioning end of the Asperger's spectrum." (I think this was somewhat sincere, that's why it's charming)
"I haven't emailed you because all I can think about is how you'll just answer me and tell me what a dick I am."
"No one really cares about the world or about people." (This is charming because it's a Francisco Hernandez reference!)
A set of pictures of rooms crammed with food, books, clothes, and possibly garbage, labeled "Life skills"
"I thought I should email you before I email my family because you'll get more nervous if I don't email you and think that I'm mad." (same person as #2--how cute is her theory of mind?)
I could say more but I don't want this list to become a Toddopoly, and I think that's likely to happen. Basically, I just feel really lucky that ASD people sometimes get in contact with me because of YouTube, because I don't know any ASD people in real life (well, one person seems ASD, but isn't diagnosed and doesn't describe herself that way). It's nice to watch people become scared in the same way that I am scared, and be careful in the same way that I'm careful.
My friend who seems ASD (who I haven't seen in eight months, but who is on campus, so I'll probably see her within the next few days) is a girl named Jane who always skips around and apologizes for things. One of my favorite things with Jane is that sometimes we both just sort of run off at the mouth using all our apology and carefulness scripts, and then we both rush to reassure each other. "I'm sorry I'm being so weird"/"No I'm sorry I'm being weird"/"But you're not being weird, it's my fault, I'm the one being weird"/"No you're not being weird, I think you're great"/"No, you're wrong, actually you're the one who's great, I think you confused the pronouns you were trying to use." It's like a puppet show after a while; the words aren't really language, just a game. A really safe game full of history.
I am not an especially good friend, by any means, but my friendship can have a systematic quality, and I don't think that's such a bad thing because I'm starting to realize how nice it is in others.
"I haven't emailed you because all I can think about is how you'll just answer me and tell me what a dick I am."
"No one really cares about the world or about people." (This is charming because it's a Francisco Hernandez reference!)
A set of pictures of rooms crammed with food, books, clothes, and possibly garbage, labeled "Life skills"
"I thought I should email you before I email my family because you'll get more nervous if I don't email you and think that I'm mad." (same person as #2--how cute is her theory of mind?)
I could say more but I don't want this list to become a Toddopoly, and I think that's likely to happen. Basically, I just feel really lucky that ASD people sometimes get in contact with me because of YouTube, because I don't know any ASD people in real life (well, one person seems ASD, but isn't diagnosed and doesn't describe herself that way). It's nice to watch people become scared in the same way that I am scared, and be careful in the same way that I'm careful.
My friend who seems ASD (who I haven't seen in eight months, but who is on campus, so I'll probably see her within the next few days) is a girl named Jane who always skips around and apologizes for things. One of my favorite things with Jane is that sometimes we both just sort of run off at the mouth using all our apology and carefulness scripts, and then we both rush to reassure each other. "I'm sorry I'm being so weird"/"No I'm sorry I'm being weird"/"But you're not being weird, it's my fault, I'm the one being weird"/"No you're not being weird, I think you're great"/"No, you're wrong, actually you're the one who's great, I think you confused the pronouns you were trying to use." It's like a puppet show after a while; the words aren't really language, just a game. A really safe game full of history.
I am not an especially good friend, by any means, but my friendship can have a systematic quality, and I don't think that's such a bad thing because I'm starting to realize how nice it is in others.
we need a name for this
"Ari Ne'eman can talk and some ASD people can't talk so he's not a good representative"
"oh so who do you think should represent ASD people"
"um, me"
"oh okay are you like a nonverbal ASD person"
"oh no, actually I don't have ASD at all"
"wait so then isn't Ari Ne'eman more ASD than you"
"yeah but for some reason 'how ASD someone is' only matters when I'm talking about people who aren't me and my friends"
"oh so who do you think should represent ASD people"
"um, me"
"oh okay are you like a nonverbal ASD person"
"oh no, actually I don't have ASD at all"
"wait so then isn't Ari Ne'eman more ASD than you"
"yeah but for some reason 'how ASD someone is' only matters when I'm talking about people who aren't me and my friends"
06 January, 2010
On genes and being flip and stuff
I don't know anyone who is blind, but I have a strange relationship to blindness because it's in my genes, and I decided a few years ago that it would be immoral for me to have biological kids because I don't believe in genetic engineering or selective abortion but I don't want to create a kid who I know will have a rough time. I mean, kids can have a rough time for a lot of reasons, and I don't really think it's moral to create a kid if you can't naturally have one with your partner*, so I think I would have come to the same conclusion anyway. But I started thinking about it because of my genes.
Also, I used to always wish I was a boy, so it would be okay for me to like girls and be overinterested in things, but if I was XY I actually wouldn't exist. Whenever my mom thinks I am being too "flip" about disabilities, she reminds me that her brother, who has the syndrome we carry, told her to abort me if I was XY. I don't know the syndrome, or my uncle, very well. I just know it gets worse as you get older. It's called Ocular Albinism Nettleship Falls and when I try to look it up on Wikipedia there's just a scientific explanation and it doesn't really help me understand what happens to a person who has it. But I guess that you have pretty bad vision when you're a kid, and it gets worse until, by the time you're in your twenties, you're legally blind.
The thing is, I feel like my uncle telling my mom to abort me is not really proof of anything innate about blindness. When I was younger I used to think that I was depressed because homosexuality is toxic and I used to think that my parents should have taken me to aversion therapy or something when I was still unformed enough that it could have changed something. I think my uncle has had a hard time because things were harder for pwds when he was a kid, and also for other reasons that aren't actually related to his disability, but it's easier to imagine that they are.
The reason my mom told me I was being flip is probably that I was being flip. I used to be on this skin medication that's really intense, and if you get pregnant while you're on it, there's a high likelihood of birth defects (according to Wikipedia, the usual ones are "hearing and visual impairment, missing earlobes, facial dysmorphism, and mental retardation"). There's this government program where everyone who goes on the medication has to go on two forms of birth control, one of which has to be the Pill. I've actually been on the Pill quite a lot considering I'm a homo--I was on it for a year or two for my skin when I was 14-15, and then I was on it for several months when I was eighteen because I was on this skin medication. I really don't like taking it, for aesthetic reasons--I just think having a fake period is weird--and besides, it leads to me crying a lot the day before my fake period starts, which I don't enjoy.
This is frustrating because my skin got super horrible while I was in the UK and it hasn't improved much since, but I really don't want to go on the medication again because I don't want to go on the Pill. It makes me sort of mad that I'm not allowed to just say I'm gay. I feel like being gay is considered to be some personal thing that I'm supposed to keep to myself in medical settings because I have to follow all the straight person rules anyway, because every XX person must be having sex with XY people.
Anyway, I was complaining to my mom about this, and I said, "isn't it kind of weird that the government is allowed to legislate against the conception of disabled babies?" and my mom said it's so people can't sue the government if they have a disabled baby, and I said, "well, can't I just sign a form saying I don't care if my baby is disabled?**" and then my mom told me that I was "flip" and "spoiled" for saying I didn't care. She was saying how hard it is if someone's poor and they have three kids and one of the kids is disabled, and I said we need better government services, and my mom says the government doesn't have unlimited resources, which is true although I do think that if stuff was better organized then we would have better services than we do now. My mom also said that I have a biased view because if I read disability blogs, then I only see the perspectives of people who are okay with being disabled.
I guess it is true that I'm flip as all get-out, but at the same time that's kind of a preemptive strike. I think I'm trying to make up for people who aren't flip enough, if that makes sense. I mean, I think our culture has this huge, heavy idea of what it's like to be related to a person with a disability, and that results in discrimination and abuse because people think that it's this difficult experience they can't possibly understand, so if someone kills their kid, or abuses their kid, or publicly talks about their kid in an abusive or threatening way, you're not supposed to react to it as if it's a cut-and-dry situation. It's supposed to be "flip" for me to say that Alison Singer (to use the classic example) did something fucked up, because I'm supposed to be intimidated by Oh My Gosh She Has An Autistic Child. I'm supposed to apply myself, to put a lot of effort into understanding the complexity of her situation. But the truth is, in my opinion, it is not complex, and it's offensive to say that it's complex.
The reason I'm talking about family members and not actual pwds is because I think our culture doesn't think much about pwds ourselves and just thinks about the people who have to take care of us. I really liked Getting the Truth Out, which was a website that deconstructed the portrayal of nonverbal people, and was basically a nonverbal ASD person writing, "hey, I'm actually a person, and way I look and the kinds of help I need are just my life, but they can be written about in really shaming language;" please, as I would say, be human, and relate to people as other humans instead of freaking out about how they seem different. Anyway, I linked it on my blog one time, and my mom said, "well, think about it--someone has to take care of that person." Which is like--so what? The person who made Getting the Truth Out was Amanda Baggs, who I believe is supported by people who do support staff work for a living, so--what's the problem, we're supposed to be upset that people have jobs? How does that make Baggs's assertion that she's a person any more complex?
So, yeah. I think that I have a tendency to act like disability isn't a difficult thing because there's a tendency in the larger culture to inflate the difficulty of disability to ridiculous levels so that people can go around doing offensive and evil things to disabled people. So I'm reacting against that, and probably being a brat, but I just get so frustrated.
Sorry this is incoherent, maybe I'll rewrite it later, especially because it's about two subjects, just some disclaimers:
*I feel weird making statements about what's moral but yeah, I think that if you need to use science in order to give birth to a kid, you should just adopt one, because a lot of people already exist who need parents. This isn't because I think that non-XX/XY couples, or XX/XY couples who are infertile, are particularly unfit to have kids. Adoption is having kids. It's wasteful to make more, but it's especially wasteful if it requires extra effort and money to do so. I'm not trying to legislate this but I feel like people let their distaste for adoption (which is really fucked up) keep them from making the logical and ethical choice.
**I'm never going to get pregnant anyway so it's not like I was seriously saying that I "don't care" about having a kid with birth defects. I personally wouldn't get pregnant in a situation where I knew that was likely; I'm just saying it's weird that people aren't given the choice to say they don't care, because they should be allowed to not care if they want.
***This is not actually a disclaimer, just something that I think is funny: some of the things disabled people's parents say are the same things liberal people say when their kids are gay. Straight people don't like having gay kids, and if they're openly homophobic, they just say this straight out, but if they're not, they tend to express their unhappiness by stating a ton of facts, such as, "gay people can't get married and have non-adopted babies," and, "if you are gay people might attack you," and, "it is harder to find a relationship if you're gay." The upshot of all these facts being, it is difficult to be gay. Thanks for the information, you guys! I had no idea!
From the limited sample of me, I think that when straight liberal parents constantly repeat facts about how hard it is to be gay, that makes it harder for their kid to be gay. And I think that some of the same stuff is true when it comes to disabilities. Stuff is hard, but emphasizing how hard it is can be a cover for prejudice.
Also, I used to always wish I was a boy, so it would be okay for me to like girls and be overinterested in things, but if I was XY I actually wouldn't exist. Whenever my mom thinks I am being too "flip" about disabilities, she reminds me that her brother, who has the syndrome we carry, told her to abort me if I was XY. I don't know the syndrome, or my uncle, very well. I just know it gets worse as you get older. It's called Ocular Albinism Nettleship Falls and when I try to look it up on Wikipedia there's just a scientific explanation and it doesn't really help me understand what happens to a person who has it. But I guess that you have pretty bad vision when you're a kid, and it gets worse until, by the time you're in your twenties, you're legally blind.
The thing is, I feel like my uncle telling my mom to abort me is not really proof of anything innate about blindness. When I was younger I used to think that I was depressed because homosexuality is toxic and I used to think that my parents should have taken me to aversion therapy or something when I was still unformed enough that it could have changed something. I think my uncle has had a hard time because things were harder for pwds when he was a kid, and also for other reasons that aren't actually related to his disability, but it's easier to imagine that they are.
The reason my mom told me I was being flip is probably that I was being flip. I used to be on this skin medication that's really intense, and if you get pregnant while you're on it, there's a high likelihood of birth defects (according to Wikipedia, the usual ones are "hearing and visual impairment, missing earlobes, facial dysmorphism, and mental retardation"). There's this government program where everyone who goes on the medication has to go on two forms of birth control, one of which has to be the Pill. I've actually been on the Pill quite a lot considering I'm a homo--I was on it for a year or two for my skin when I was 14-15, and then I was on it for several months when I was eighteen because I was on this skin medication. I really don't like taking it, for aesthetic reasons--I just think having a fake period is weird--and besides, it leads to me crying a lot the day before my fake period starts, which I don't enjoy.
This is frustrating because my skin got super horrible while I was in the UK and it hasn't improved much since, but I really don't want to go on the medication again because I don't want to go on the Pill. It makes me sort of mad that I'm not allowed to just say I'm gay. I feel like being gay is considered to be some personal thing that I'm supposed to keep to myself in medical settings because I have to follow all the straight person rules anyway, because every XX person must be having sex with XY people.
Anyway, I was complaining to my mom about this, and I said, "isn't it kind of weird that the government is allowed to legislate against the conception of disabled babies?" and my mom said it's so people can't sue the government if they have a disabled baby, and I said, "well, can't I just sign a form saying I don't care if my baby is disabled?**" and then my mom told me that I was "flip" and "spoiled" for saying I didn't care. She was saying how hard it is if someone's poor and they have three kids and one of the kids is disabled, and I said we need better government services, and my mom says the government doesn't have unlimited resources, which is true although I do think that if stuff was better organized then we would have better services than we do now. My mom also said that I have a biased view because if I read disability blogs, then I only see the perspectives of people who are okay with being disabled.
I guess it is true that I'm flip as all get-out, but at the same time that's kind of a preemptive strike. I think I'm trying to make up for people who aren't flip enough, if that makes sense. I mean, I think our culture has this huge, heavy idea of what it's like to be related to a person with a disability, and that results in discrimination and abuse because people think that it's this difficult experience they can't possibly understand, so if someone kills their kid, or abuses their kid, or publicly talks about their kid in an abusive or threatening way, you're not supposed to react to it as if it's a cut-and-dry situation. It's supposed to be "flip" for me to say that Alison Singer (to use the classic example) did something fucked up, because I'm supposed to be intimidated by Oh My Gosh She Has An Autistic Child. I'm supposed to apply myself, to put a lot of effort into understanding the complexity of her situation. But the truth is, in my opinion, it is not complex, and it's offensive to say that it's complex.
The reason I'm talking about family members and not actual pwds is because I think our culture doesn't think much about pwds ourselves and just thinks about the people who have to take care of us. I really liked Getting the Truth Out, which was a website that deconstructed the portrayal of nonverbal people, and was basically a nonverbal ASD person writing, "hey, I'm actually a person, and way I look and the kinds of help I need are just my life, but they can be written about in really shaming language;" please, as I would say, be human, and relate to people as other humans instead of freaking out about how they seem different. Anyway, I linked it on my blog one time, and my mom said, "well, think about it--someone has to take care of that person." Which is like--so what? The person who made Getting the Truth Out was Amanda Baggs, who I believe is supported by people who do support staff work for a living, so--what's the problem, we're supposed to be upset that people have jobs? How does that make Baggs's assertion that she's a person any more complex?
So, yeah. I think that I have a tendency to act like disability isn't a difficult thing because there's a tendency in the larger culture to inflate the difficulty of disability to ridiculous levels so that people can go around doing offensive and evil things to disabled people. So I'm reacting against that, and probably being a brat, but I just get so frustrated.
Sorry this is incoherent, maybe I'll rewrite it later, especially because it's about two subjects, just some disclaimers:
*I feel weird making statements about what's moral but yeah, I think that if you need to use science in order to give birth to a kid, you should just adopt one, because a lot of people already exist who need parents. This isn't because I think that non-XX/XY couples, or XX/XY couples who are infertile, are particularly unfit to have kids. Adoption is having kids. It's wasteful to make more, but it's especially wasteful if it requires extra effort and money to do so. I'm not trying to legislate this but I feel like people let their distaste for adoption (which is really fucked up) keep them from making the logical and ethical choice.
**I'm never going to get pregnant anyway so it's not like I was seriously saying that I "don't care" about having a kid with birth defects. I personally wouldn't get pregnant in a situation where I knew that was likely; I'm just saying it's weird that people aren't given the choice to say they don't care, because they should be allowed to not care if they want.
***This is not actually a disclaimer, just something that I think is funny: some of the things disabled people's parents say are the same things liberal people say when their kids are gay. Straight people don't like having gay kids, and if they're openly homophobic, they just say this straight out, but if they're not, they tend to express their unhappiness by stating a ton of facts, such as, "gay people can't get married and have non-adopted babies," and, "if you are gay people might attack you," and, "it is harder to find a relationship if you're gay." The upshot of all these facts being, it is difficult to be gay. Thanks for the information, you guys! I had no idea!
From the limited sample of me, I think that when straight liberal parents constantly repeat facts about how hard it is to be gay, that makes it harder for their kid to be gay. And I think that some of the same stuff is true when it comes to disabilities. Stuff is hard, but emphasizing how hard it is can be a cover for prejudice.
Labels:
asd,
blind,
disability rights,
gay,
genes
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
