31 March, 2010

so good

me: Liam, my mom's friend told me to date you
it was so awful
she was like "Amanda, you seem to be friends with a lot of boys, why don't you consider dating them"
Liam: whaaat?
oh no
me: and I was like "no thanks, I'm not interested in boys that way" and she was like "no relationship is perfect"
she was like "when you were talking about your friend Liam your face just lit up"
I was like "that's because I was talking about Christian the lion"
Liam: haha
me: I think she was excited because she's Irish
she got excited about your name
then when she left she was like "say hi to Liam"
Liam: oh no that is so weird
me: I knowww
so weird
and I kept trying to argue
Liam: im sorry indirectly
me: oh no I mean I think it's really funny
don't be sorry
I was like "the reason I don't get along with girls is because I like them, if I liked guys I wouldn't get along with guys. like when I was younger and didn't know I was gay I used to be like 'it would be so easy if I was gay, girls are so easy to talk to'"
and then she was like, "so being gay seemed like an escape from your problems!!"
Liam: :(
me: no it was classic
I love old people
Liam: haha
oh man
what are they trying to accomplish?
me: I don't know
who will ever know

30 March, 2010

Good Behavior and Psychoanalysis

Jelly told me about this person named Smockity Frocks who is a Christian homeschooling blogger and apparently never heard of disabled people before in her life. She took her post down and replaced it with a link to Autism Speaks (of course, because it's better to eradicate people with disabilities than treat them with charity and understanding) but it's cached here: http://docs.google.com/fileview?id=0B5C2Ta2YGCfTYmRhOTliZTUtNjQ5ZC00MmNjLWJmYzItNWU5MjNlYzU4ZTc3&hl=en

Basically, her post was about how she was at the library with her kids, READING THE BIBLE (for some reason that's my favorite part), and this other kid was waiting for the computer that SF's daughter was using. The other kid got very frustrated by waiting and started flapping her hands and saying, "I'm being really patient," to which her grandmother would reply, "Yes, you're being very patient, soon you'll be able to use the computer." So SF made a post about how no one understands how to treat kids anymore, and this kid was majorly spoiled and wasn't actually being patient at all, or something.

Then a bunch of people commented on it and were like, "This kid obviously has ASD and you fail at being Christian." Smockity Frocks was like, "Well, her grandmother should have made her read a book instead." Then the other people said, "That might not have worked with a kid who has ASD," and it all climaxed with Smockity Frocks declaring, "Well, YOU'RE not being very Christian YOURSELF, because what if I have a disability that keeps me from being able to tolerate kids who are BRATS??"

Oh, boy. There is a collection of response posts here from people whose kids have disabilities: A Message for Smockity Frocks. I haven't read them all but I like Kristina Chew's post a lot. Jelly also wrote a post, which is really good: Oh the joys of judgmental people. From my not especially thorough skimming, it seems like Jelly is the only ASD person who has written a post.

This was striking to me because I've been having a lot of trouble with waiting lately. I've said I've been having shutdowns but that's not really true because they're not really a state of bluntedness or distance, which is how I think of shutdowns; at the same time I don't want to call them meltdowns because I don't actually do anything. They're like proto-meltdowns, and they happen in situations like this, when I'm waiting for something to happen, or something to be over, and I get so tremendously agitated that I feel like I'm going to have...well, a regular meltdown. Which isn't practical since I'm 21. To stop it from happening I start trying to scratch myself with pens and stuff.

I'm sure that if someone looks around the room when a class is running long and sees me gritting my teeth and scratching my arms with a pen, it probably looks to them like I'm being a jerk and trying to tell everyone how much I don't like the class, but this isn't the case. Trying to judge other people's morals is a terrible idea, and CS Lewis explains this much better than I can in the chapter of Mere Christianity called Morality and Psychoanalysis. (I think this chapter isn't that specific to Christianity and can still be useful and interesting if you're not Christian.) CSL points out that you don't know what is happening to a person inside and it's not fair to just judge them by what they do because you don't know what they're fighting against.

[Note: I know that CSL equates homosexuality with having a phobia of cats. I think this is actually pretty charitable given his time period and culture, because he understands that a person can't help being gay and a gay person can be moral, or at least move in a moral direction. Obviously your mileage may vary, but I think he has a good attitude given his raw material.]

This is part of why instead of saying "high-functioning," "low-functioning," etc., I like to say "severely affected," "mildly affected," and so on. This means that instead of thinking about what the person appears to be doing, I'm thinking about what they are working against or around. This seems like a fairer and more accurate way of thinking about people.

The greatest story ever told: At the ASD school where I interned last summer, they used to take the kids on the subway. A lot of the kids had trouble taking the subway and their aides would try to make things easier, for example they'd hold a big clipboard in front of the kid showing how many points the kid was earning by being well-behaved. Also some of the kids would wear iPods on the subway.

Another thing that made the experience easier was being able to sit down. If people didn't offer their seats to the kids, the aides would sometimes ask. Apparently, one time they asked this woman if she could move over so one of the kids, who not only disliked standing, but also had a cold, could sit down. So she very slightly moved over and sat there glaring at the kid, who was squished in next to her. AND THEN HE SNEEZED ON HER FACE.

someone is right on the Internet

"When I tip over a carton of milk, I don't rush around demanding a cure for gravity...I first deal with the immediate problem by righting the carton and wiping up the spill."--Don Sakers in the AS livejournal community

28 March, 2010

sorry about posting 400 times today

but I have sort of been crashing, and I really liked this poem when it was in the New Yorker in 2002 the week my dog died, and it's a poem that I find myself thinking of, well, always when I am crashing. I just got home for break, and my mom has been going to workshops at the Autism Spectrum Resource Center and she was telling me about the people and I asked, "Are there any Amandas?" and my mom said, "no, there's no one as high-functioning as you." Also whenever my mom tells anyone I have Asperger's she says "But she's very high-functioning" even though I'm standing right there so I'd think the person would be able to tell if I'm high-functioning or not.

Anyway, I guess my question is if I'm so high-functioning why can't I do anything. I know the answer is that I can do a lot of things, for example we went to dinner with my grandmother and aunts and uncles and cousins and it was easy and no big deal, also my dad started a long conversation with me when I was doing something else, and I didn't whine or anything. Sometimes when this stuff is going on it just strikes me how easy it is now. I know that's good. It just frequently doesn't feel like enough. It turns into this creepy tug-of-war, like how I love going to the airport because I can take off my shoes and put my computer in the tray and go through the metal detector, and I love taking trains and subways because I know how, but then people ask me to do things that make me so upset, like my professor telling me we're going to have class on Tuesday instead of Thursday so I have to change my shift at work. When this happened I wrote on my knee:

"Life Is An Endless Mess"

and while I know this is dramatic, it sometimes feels that way and makes me want to cry.

I was thinking about my self-injury because when I did it I didn't have very stereotypical motivations. I basically did it to win the tug-of-war. Some people supposedly don't feel it or they like the way it feels but I always felt it, and I did it because I thought that other people wouldn't have been able to keep going, but I kept going to make up for all the other situations in which I couldn't keep going.

Anyway, this is the poem:

The Promotion
by James Tate

I was a dog in my former life, a very good
dog, and, thus, I was promoted to a human being.
I liked being a dog. I worked for a poor farmer,
guarding and herding his sheep. Wolves and coyotes
tried to get past me almost every night, and not
once did I lose a sheep. The farmer rewarded me
with good food, food from his table. He may have
been poor, but he ate well. And his children
played with me, when they weren't in school or
working in the field. I had all the love any dog
could hope for. When I got old, they got a new
dog, and I trained him in the tricks of the trade.
He quickly learned, and the farmer brought me into
the house to live with the family. I brought the farmer
his slippers in the morning, as he was getting
old, too. I was dying slowly, a little bit at a
time. The farmer knew this and would bring the
new dog in to visit me from time to time. The
new dog would entertain me with his flips and
flops and nuzzles. And then one morning I just
didn't get up. They gave me a fine burial down
by the stream under a shade tree. That was the
end of my being a dog. Sometimes I miss it so
I sit by my window and cry. I live in a high-rise
that looks out at a bunch of other high-rises.
At my job I work in a cubicle and barely speak
to anyone all day. The human wolves don't even see me.
They fear me not.

[I know this is the most emo post ever made, but if you want, you can bookmark it and then read it when you're feeling emo yourself and are in a state to handle it. If you read it when you're in a normal mood you might end up holding me in contempt forever.]

this is a transcript, obviously

Hey, so I can't remember if this wasn't recent or if it was a while ago, but my friend Todd was like, "How come you don't make any YouTube videos anymore?" and I was like, "Todd, um, I can't talk, that's why I don't make videos."

Like I feel like the reason I was making them in the first place was just as an experiment in talking, because I usually don't talk because I don't talk very well, so I realized it was kind of cool to make YouTube videos because I could practice saying things as many times as I wanted, or I could just say things and never post them but just listen to them and listen to how I talk. It's just really exciting to have the freedom to talk when you usually don't talk because you're a shitty speaker.

So that's my thing, and I don't know why Todd can't just read my blog, or he could call me on the phone and then he could listen to how horribly I talk--but then I guess he couldn't see me fidgeting around, which is maybe the best part.

Well, something happened, current events. It involves a person that I know but I really don't like to say his name because it has too many vowels in it--see, this is why I can't make videos, this kind of shit is actually sincerely upsetting to me because it's hard for me to say words that have too many vowels in them. That's why I don't talk. Well. This is his name. [holds up hand that says "Ari Ne'eman" on it, and carries on about that situation for a while, but I'm not transcribing most of that because I already posted about it twice]

...Do we need autistic mice? They would be cute, but what's even cuter, I think, is kids with severe autism getting an education so that they can communicate. I think that would be even more adorable than autistic mice...

I think I was going to talk about the idea of cure but the problem is that it's so nebulous to me and it feels so personal that it's hard for me to really say that I'm anti-cure--or what I like to say, rhetorically, is that I'm pro-cure and that I would take a cure pill, but just that I don't think, um, that I don't think it's particularly likely or easy, so.

I guess, okay. I would take a cure pill now, I think. Yeah, I can say that for sure. You know, it just makes stuff harder. But because stuff has been harder, I've realized, you know--I haven't had all the options that other people have had, I guess, I haven't been able to say, "I'm going to do this when I grow up," because I know that there are a lot of things, because I can't talk very well, and certain other things that are not going to be really possible--so I think, because of that I became interested in working with people with disabilities which really has been hugely meaningful to me, and if that hadn't happened, if I'd had all these options I'm afraid that that wouldn't have been the case. I also--I feel that my love for people is different and almost more tender because it's been so hard for me to be close to people and understand them that when it happens it's almost such a shock that it's sort of miraculous.

I guess my problem is I just don't necessarily have a very standard way of looking at things and whether things are good or bad, and I know, objectively, that having a disability, I think makes your life worse, but I mean, I mean, I mean, I can see how that's true if you write it all down, like, mathematically, I guess it's all worse, but it's just like, I feel that my life has been so meaningful to me through my disability and through other people's disabilities that it's really difficult for me to say "I don't want disabilities to exist."

I mean, if you don't want pain and disability to exist, like, instead of trying to figure out the gene for autism or continuing to abort fetuses with the gene for Down Syndrome--I mean, I think that the condition of pain and difficulty is called, um, "life," and I think every fetus has the gene for life, so I think it might be better if people just stopped living or having babies, if you really want life to not have difficulty in it.

But, I mean, okay, I feel concerned saying this because I know that this is, like, a political issue, but for me, I guess it's really hard for me to think about it because it feels philosophical and religious to me, and, I don't know. I haven't read this so I probably shouldn't talk about it, but I read about a woman who was a disabled Christian theologian, and she wrote books talking about Christ as a disabled person, since He was a person who was injured and in pain, and I feel, I don't know, I guess it's hard for me to, as a Christian person, to see the condition of injury and incompleteness, to see those things as something that I have and other people don't. I feel like it's clearer for me, sometimes I almost feel luckier because I feel like it's pretty easy for me to understand that I have a bunch of original sin going on because I'm not very good at hiding anything that I'm thinking or feeling, so I just know about it.

Yeah, I'm sorry to say this. I guess this isn't political, except the beginning, you should support Ari, but um, it's just difficult for me to think about disability the way that you're supposed to think about it. It's kind of like, um, what's the line, it's from Serenity, you know when the Operative is talking about the better world or whatever and he says, "Oh, I'm not going to live in the better world." Like, hypothetically, I understand that a world without disability is in some form a better world, right?

But I mean, I just don't want it, you know, I feel like if we get a world without disabilities I feel like I'm just gonna hop into a time machine and go back somewhere where we have them again, because I just don't understand the point of life without disabilities. Um, yeah, I don't know--is this a weird thing to think?

I mean, I know people with severe disabilities and I feel for them a lot when they're in pain so I don't think it's that I don't understand what disability is, that I think it's just a little thing, but it's just, it's hard for me to think that we should just get rid of it I guess--yeah, that's all.

I support Ari Ne'eman, part two

Hi.

I am an ASD person. But, something that I think is equally important, if not more so: for a few years I have volunteered with people who have mild, moderate, and severe developmental disabilities. I know a lot of DD people with different levels of impairment. I want to work with severely DD people after I graduate from college.

I care very much about people who are not "high-functioning," and I wouldn't support Ari if I didn't think he felt the same way. I used to not like him very much because I had gotten the impression that he was one of those "a dash of autism creates a genius" windbags. I later realized that this wasn't the case and was more a function of the way he was portrayed by popular news outlets, who were more interested in writing a gimmicky article about his disability than expressing what he actually believes and is actually doing. He has worked a lot on keeping people with disabilities from being abused in schools and institutions--an issue which generally affects people who are more severely disabled. He has also made comments that show he is not a Shiny Aspie, for example in this New York Times article from November:

“My identity is attached to being on the autism spectrum, not some superior Asperger’s identity...I think the consolidation to one category of autism spectrum diagnosis will lead to better services.”

The people who have campaigned against his nomination and confirmation are generally people who don't like the idea of ASD people expressing opinions--especially opinions that are anti-cure. They set up being anti-cure as being anti-severely disabled people. But I couldn't disagree more.

I've written several times about a school for ASD kids where I interned last summer. I have a lot of criticisms of the way this school is run, for example the fact that they are anti-stimming. However, because the school has a 1:1 teacher:student ratio and most of the teachers are really devoted to their jobs--plus the highly notable fact that every nonverbal kid gets an AAC device--kids with severe ASD are able to make a lot of progress. Every kid can communicate at least a little using their AAC device and understand schedules and instructions; and there are kids at the school who were nonverbal and have become highly verbal.

In Ohio, I know kids who have problems (including but not limited to ASD) that lead to them having trouble talking, looking at things, and paying attention. They generally don't have a person working with them 1:1 who is doing exactly what is necessary to help the kid pay attention and learn. So, they are way behind the ASD kids at the school where I interned.

The school where I interned is a charter school that kids with Autistic Disorder and PDD-NOS can get into by lottery, when there's a free space. It has the resources to serve 28 students. If you're a rich person with a severely ASD kid and you can't get them into that school, you can try to put them in a private school. If you're not rich, your kid can go to public school and be in a big special ed class where people will maybe sometimes pay attention to them, occasionally, and maybe that will or won't help your kid learn something or other.

The reason I'm anti-cure...well, I may not be anti-cure theoretically (I don't know if I am) but I am practically....and the reason I'm anti-cure is that there are lots of things you can do to help people with severe disabilities, but there isn't enough money. But there is a lot of money going to research. If everyone was anti-cure, the charter school could serve more than 28 kids.

But I do think ASD mice would be really cute.